Audience speculation kept the season alive long before the finale aired.
Season 3 of The Summer I Turned Pretty centered on the question: Conrad or Jeremiah? Fans fiercely debated all season, and the finale gave an answer that sparked even more discussion.
With the conclusion of The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 3, fans and cast members alike faced an emotional farewell. The Prime Video series has not only captured the essence of teenage summer romance but also created one of the most talked-about debates in recent TV history: Who will Belly choose in the end?
This single question carried the season, dominated fan discussions, and became the lens through which every episode was judged. Let’s look at the predictions people made, how they felt about Belly’s choice, and why those reactions mattered as Season 3 wrapped up.
Team Conrad vs. Team Jeremiah
From the first episodes of Season 3, fans split into two passionate groups.
- Team Conrad supporters believed that Belly and Conrad shared an undeniable bond. Many argued that his quieter, more complicated love reflected a deeper connection, one that couldn’t be replaced by comfort or ease.
- Team Jeremiah supporters countered that Belly deserved stability. They pointed out Jeremiah’s openness, loyalty, and ability to make her feel safe, suggesting that choosing him meant choosing a healthier future.
These arguments weren’t abstract. People actively compared scenes, replayed dialogue, and highlighted moments they felt proved their side. Social media comments, fan blogs, and watch-party threads all centered on this choice, making it the most pressing question of the season.
What Fans Said About the Possibilities
Audience predictions gave Season 3 its energy. Before the finale aired:
Some said Belly would stay with Jeremiah, noting that his steady devotion aligned with the growth she needed. “Jeremiah never makes her question herself,” one fan wrote, reflecting the sentiment that his love was more supportive.
Others insisted Conrad was endgame, pointing to scenes where his feelings were clear but unspoken. A popular refrain was that Belly and Conrad had a history too strong to ignore.
A smaller group believed the finale would leave Belly on her own, arguing that the healthiest ending would be about independence and self-discovery.
The intensity of these predictions showed how deeply people were invested. For many, the finale wasn’t just about storytelling — it was about whether the showrunners would honor what fans had been hoping (or fearing) all season.
The Season 3 Finale and Fan Reactions
When the finale aired, it confirmed what much of the conversation had built toward: Belly leaning back toward Conrad. For his supporters, this felt like vindication after weeks of debate. Reactions described the ending as “the payoff we waited three seasons for.”
For Jeremiah fans, however, the finale sparked disappointment. Many voiced frustration that his loyalty was overlooked and said the decision reinforced the “bad boy always wins” trope.
Still, even critical reactions underscored the show’s impact. People weren’t casual viewers; they were emotionally invested enough to defend their side long after the credits rolled.
How We Know: Using Data to Track Audience Buzz
So how can we say with confidence what fans expected, and how their voices shaped the story? This is where data comes in. By analyzing audience discussions and the themes that gained the most traction, we can see which predictions carried the most weight.
This is exactly what our tool, Trending Content, was built to do. It gathers data from across online conversations, highlights which topics people care about most, and shows the exact themes driving attention. For The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 3, that meant identifying how much energy went into debating Belly’s choice — and which predictions fans believed were most likely.
For example, we searched for the keyword “The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 3” and found a flood of discussion threads around the finale. By leveraging those conversations and using advanced AI to summarize them, we were able to understand audience sentiment and identify the strongest opinions.
From there, we shaped FAQs directly around the comments and pulled long-tail keywords that reflect the exact phrases fans were using. This approach not only captures real viewer reactions but also creates content that has a higher chance of being surfaced in Google’s AI Overviews.
It’s designed for creators, SEO teams, and marketers who want to see what real conversations are happening online — and then use them to create timely, relevant, friendly content.
Read also: How Trending Content Helps You Track Conversations and Find Good Topics to Write About
How Trending Content Works
- Track Reddit and YouTube Threads by Keyword
Type in any topic — “The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 3 ending,” “best AI tools for solopreneurs,” “clean skincare routine,” “freelancer tax tips” — and see the top discussions driving attention. - Extract Long-Tail Keywords and Questions
Pull exact phrases and questions from real user language, giving you the terms people are actually searching for right now. - Shape Your Content to Match Audience Demand
Use naturally phrased questions as H2s, answer them directly, and keep the tone clear and conversational. Add bullet points, comparisons, and first-hand context where possible. - Accelerate Your Writing Process
Transform insights into SEO outlines and AI-ready drafts in minutes, saving hours of manual research.
For The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 3, this meant we could see exactly how strongly fans leaned toward Conrad or Jeremiah — and how those opinions aligned with the finale’s outcome.
Looking Beyond Season 3
While the finale tied up Season 3’s love triangle, it isn’t the end of the story. Jenny Han, the series creator and showrunner, confirmed that a movie will serve as the true conclusion.
- “There is another big milestone left in Belly’s journey, and I thought only a movie could give it its proper due,” Han said in a press release.
- Amazon MGM executives added: “We’re proud of the series’ extraordinary success and couldn’t be more excited to partner again with Jenny Han to bring fans an unforgettable next chapter.”
With Han writing and directing, and cast members expected to return, the movie promises to deliver closure in a way that honors both the books and the fan-driven energy that has defined the series.
A Fan-Driven Season
Season 3 of The Summer I Turned Pretty will be remembered for its love triangle, but more importantly, for how fans shaped its narrative. Predictions, debates, and emotional investment weren’t side notes — they were the center of the season’s energy.
As the show transitions into its final movie, one truth is clear: audience voices mattered. For fans, it meant their predictions weren’t just speculation. For creators, it proved that listening to viewers can shape the heart of a story.
FAQs
Who did fans think Belly would choose in Season 3?
Most predictions split between Conrad and Jeremiah, with smaller groups hoping she would choose independence.
Who does Belly actually end up with in Season 3?
The finale leaned toward Conrad, echoing much of the audience sentiment leading up to the final episodes.
Is Season 3 the last season of The Summer I Turned Pretty?
No. A movie has been announced as the final chapter, written and directed by Jenny Han.
Will the cast of The Summer I Turned Pretty return for the movie?
Yes. Lola Tung, Christopher Briney, and Gavin Casalegno are all expected to reprise their roles.
How did fans react to the Season 3 finale?
Conrad fans celebrated the ending, while Jeremiah supporters voiced disappointment, fueling ongoing debate.
